Boundary Waters - Baker, Cherokee, and Sawbill Lakes Route


As we descended into Duluth and saw the deep blue waters of Lake Superior, Matt switched to the music mode on his phone and tuned into the song, “The Ballad of the Edmond Fitzgerald” and its lyrics about “the big lake they call Gitche-Gumee.” He remembered how he and I, along with the rest of the family, sang this song continuously when we were last up this way nearly twenty years ago on a houseboat vacation.

For this trip though, he and I were reliving the times when we took various canoe expeditions in the nearby Boundary Waters Canoe Area Wilderness back when he was still in high school. While I have been back up here several times with other canoe partners, our last trip here together was at the end of his senior year, just weeks before he was to head out to Marine Corp bootcamp. He and I haven’t been back since. In fact, we haven’t had much of chance for father/son time ever since then what with careers, growing families, the passage of time, and the distances apart (he lives in Texas, while I am in Illinois).

Just as we arrived at the Baker Lake landing, a big female moose splashed about along the shoreline opposite from where we were going to load the canoe. Behind her we could see how the birch and aspen trees were just starting to bud with their florescent green and still young leaves contrasting with the deeper green hues of the year-round needles on the pine, fir, and spruce trees that dominated the hillsides.


In the shaded and shallow depressions of the forest floor, remnants of snow could still be seen. It wasn’t too long ago that these lakes were still frozen solid with winter’s ice. There were still two weeks left in the month of May, the earliest we have been up here, and spring was still trying to makes its arrival.

Matt sprinkles an offering of tobacco to the Ojibway spirits, for good luck and a safe journey.





We trolled lures behind the canoe as we paddled north toward South Temperance Lake where we planned on stopping for the evening. A smallish northern pike struck my lure, our first fish of the trip. After returning it to the water, we looked up into the small bay to our left to see yet another moose thrashing about along the shoreline. This one’s winter coat was molting off of her, giving it a mottled appearance.




Matt easily lifted and hoisted his 75-pound aluminum canoe onto his shoulders to then make his way down the various portage trails connecting the lakes we were paddling on. I could hardly drag the canoe, let along lift it. That is why, in large part, that I decided to bequeath to him this canoe several years ago, choosing instead to rent lighter weight fiberglass models for any canoe tripping I have done since.



Matt, on the other hand, liked the old-school nostalgia of this family relic and insisted on taking it with us on this trip. So, being a big and strong guy (as opposed to me, a big and weak guy), we agreed before the trip that he would do all of the canoe carries on the portages while I would task myself with the much easier and old-man friendly hauling of the various backpacks, fishing rods, paddles and other loose gear.


After a while, though, the homemade yoke system Matt had fashioned to help soften the weight of the canoe on his shoulders and neck began to fail. The word ‘portage’ began to be associated with the word ‘pain’ as the metal canoe thwarts wreaked havoc on his neck and vertebrae. This became most apparent while traversing the 265 rod (3/4 mile) portage leading into South Temperance Lake.

We took a break at the mid-point just as a rotting tree chose at that moment to fall and crash right next to us just a few yards away. We wondered if it would have made a sound had we not been there when it happened.

As we shrugged off this philosophical question, we scrounged around in our bags and began to test how other pads, pillows, and pack items could be used to soften the blow to his neck. We had a lot of portages to traverse in the coming days and finding a solution to this problem was growing in importance with each carry.

It was now late afternoon and time to find a campsite for the evening. Unfortunately, all of the prime sites on South Temperance were already filled with other canoeists. This left just one possible alternative site in a far eastern arm of the lake just before it connected into big Brule Lake. Our spirits lifted as we found it was empty, spacious, cozy, and more than inviting after our long day.  




We woke the next morning to robin’s egg blue skies, warming temperatures, and fair winds. An extra bonus was that there were still no bugs. Yet. There is plenty of wood up here in these parts. We should have knocked on some for we would be tormented by them in the next day or so.

One of those still mornings where it is difficult to discern the difference between what is the sky and what is a reflection.


From South Temperance Lake, the portage took us to North Temperance Lake and a brief paddle along its southern shoreline. We fished here for a bit while contemplating the route ahead. What lay before us was a grueling pair of 100 and 175 rod (1/2 mile) portages interrupted by a short paddle on Sitka Lake, the highest point of land on our trek, before reaching the day’s final destination in Cherokee Lake.

Pre-trip research cautioned that the latter of these two portages was notorious for its ups and downs, twists and turns, and mud choked and swampy depressions. It also took us up and over the Laurentian Divide where waters to the east flow toward the Great Lakes and the St. Lawrence Seaway while waters to the west flow towards Hudson Bay and the Arctic latitudes.

Matt turned into beast mode as he hoisted the canoe and grunted his way over these demanding and punishing portages. Halfway across the Notorious Portage, I knew that the route we had planned in the coming days would have to be altered when, with a grimace on his face and sweat dripping off of his nose, Matt growled, “this portage can suck my d**k.”



We found a beautiful southwest facing campsite on Cherokee with long distance views of the lake interrupted with several small and sublime intervening islands. We would spend the next two days here fishing its shorelines, inviting bays, and deep-water holes While overall fishing was very slow, Matt was able to successfully land a good-sized northern pike with his efforts.












It wasn’t until day two at this campsite that I made quite an interesting and pleasurable discovery. Deep in the hollowed-out end of a big log we had been sitting on while enjoying our evening’s campfire, I found a full 1.5-liter bottle of un-opened vodka with its seal still intact. Somehow, the seal soon found itself broken, which then allowed me to safely and confidently mix cold lake water with a generous snort (or two). I relished its deliciousness as I toasted those before us who obviously had forgotten to take it with them. I can hear them now:

“Where is the vodka?”

“I thought you had it.”

“No, I thought you had it!”

“What?!”

“You’re an idiot!!”

“Yeah, well you’re a dumba*s!”

And so on.



Anyhow, while I sipped my cocktail and Matt smoked a cigar, we discussed if we should alter the route given the canoe-yoke-equals-pain issues and the fact that we had many long portages to come. We concluded that the best course of action was to change plans.



Picture in your mind having a map before you and tracing on it a route in the shape of a backward facing letter “P”. We were currently at the top left of the backward “P” just before it curves downward. The bottom of the stem of the “P” is where our car is parked at Baker Lake and where we were to head toward and return to as part of our originally designed route. 

Now, instead imagine an upside-down letter “U”. We were currently at the top left of this upside-down letter “U” just as it curves downward. Instead of following the backward “P” shaped route, we agreed to take the left-hand stem of an upside-down “U” shaped route where, at the bottom of this stem, we would find the Sawbill Lake landing. Once there, we hoped we could hitch a ride from another friendly canoeist or from the outfitter located nearby and travel by car or truck via the gravel forest road system back to our car at Baker Lake.  

Comforted with the satisfaction of knowing the new and altered route we had before us, we turned in, falling asleep to the distant, and sometimes nearby, haunting and wailing cries of the resident lake loons. Turn up the volume to listen to this recording that Matt was able to make of them:


The following morning, a beaver slapped his tail several times on the surface of the water right next to our campsite as a warning against something he found threatening. This was followed by the shrill call from yet another loon in what had become a familiar sound throughout our trip. The sun had barely risen when we were wakened by these sounds of nature.

Unlike other evenings, I didn’t sleep well last night. I tossed and turned which kept me from the deep and restful slumber that I had otherwise grown accustomed to during the previous nights. I was too warm and somewhat head-achy as well. The latter I blamed on the lack of proper hydration during the day. Certainly, the two generous helpings of vodka and lake water cocktails from last evening couldn’t have been the cause, right? 

We broke camp and headed south into the wind toward the far corner of the lake where a winding creek served as passage toward our next camp in the northern portion of Sawbill Lake. In past trips, I was always in the rear seat acting as canoe steerer and navigator. For this trip, Matt has taken on this role while I sat in front. His skills proved sharp for he was able to expertly guide us through the complexities of route-finding around the oftentimes puzzling blend of islands, bays, and the indiscernible differences of the innumerable shorelines.



A rugged and tiring series of muddy portages and short paddles, along with a beaver dam or two that we were able to power through and over, are what we first had to confront and overcome during the next three to four hours. Unknown to us, and not until we heard and then saw its large wings flapping as it flew away, was a bald eagle that moments before was viewing our efforts from its perch on a snag of a dead tree far above us.

The creek through which we paddled narrowed down to passage not much greater than the width of a car. At some points we were able to float through. At other points we had to pole, using our paddles on the muddy and rocky bottom to propel us through. And on occasion, we simply had to get out and walk the canoe, relieving it of our body weight so that it would float up and over rocks and other invisible underwater features.






Soon, in yet another swampy area with boot-sucking and knee-high mud, the black flies descended upon us. Up until now, we hadn’t had any issues with the bugs. The warming weather must have triggered a hatch for we were now engulfed by them. Eyes, ears, nostrils, exposed skin…nothing was spared.

Headnets and bandanas are deployed in our fight against the tormenting blackflies.


When we finally reached Sawbill Lake, the otherwise reviled headwinds were more than welcomed for they kept the bugs at bay. Into these winds we paddled on this beautiful lake past one campsite after another, finding them all filled with other canoeists who had arrived earlier in the day. Like us, they too must have known this lake’s beauty was too much not to camp on and enjoy.

Just as we were about to give up, and just as we paddled up to the last site in this portion of the lake where we happily, as well as gratefully, found it to be empty, did a fighter of a smallmouth bass slam Matt’s trolling lure. After its release, we wearily landed the canoe and set up camp for our last evening of the trip.







More attempts at catching fish ruled the following morning as we headed south toward the landing. If there was any disappointment in this trip, it would be the very slow fishing. We weren’t alone. All of those we paddled past on the lakes or passed by on the portages said that they too weren’t having too much luck landing any fish. Sometimes, that’s just the way things go.

At the landing, we found someone to drive Matt over to Baker Lake to retrieve his car. Upon his return to the Sawbill Lake landing, we loaded up our waiting canoe and gear that we had strewn all over the shoreline. For the occasion, I had left behind a few cans of beer in the trunk. They were still somewhat cold as we popped their tops and toasted each other on our successful trip, one that we will soon have to do together again.



Ahh, the adventure of it all! Oftentimes, no wilderness trip is truly worthwhile unless it requires great effort and, at times, a level of discomfort, that need to be overcome. It is only then that one can truly feel the deep satisfaction of being greeted at the end of the day with multi-colored sunsets, a filling meal, a cheery campfire, and, in my case, a relaxing conversation and reconnection with my son.



A video of our trip can be viewed at the following link:




To read and learn more about our other adventures and journeys from around the world, please go to our homepage by clicking here.

Comments